Tuesday, June 21, 2011

Disruptive physician or threat to the hierarchy? Watch out for the Kool-Aid



No doubt you’ve been aware of the latest survey on the topic of disruptive behavior in health care. The results of our joint study with QuantiaMD are the same as our ACPE survey nearly two years ago. We physicians still have a lot of work to do in our own house to solve this patient safety issue. We’re making progress. But it’s time to look at another angle of how physicians become labeled as “disruptive”. Sometimes the label is just plain wrong. Like old Hollywood westerns, or Patrick Swayze movies, the hero is often bullied by powerful people and organizations who feel that their authority is threatened, or who perceive that the status quo might change.

Since this latest study was published, I’ve had lots of interesting discussions with physicians, and senior health system leaders. Some senior leaders who come from non-health care industries comment on the odd culture of health care compared to many other industries. They point out (it’s also my experience) that disagreement, rather than being viewed as a strong cultural attribute for innovation and change, is frequently considered a threat to the hierarchy. Sometimes decision-making is highly centralized in the C-suite, and leaders are very uncomfortable with questions or differing opinions. In these health systems, the organizational Kool-Aid demands “loyalty” to the leaders, rather than legitimate, truthful debate about the merits of strategy, policies, or procedures. More about “loyalty” later!

When faced with a physician who voices distaste with the Kool-Aid of mindless agreement, these leaders label her/him “disruptive” – not because of behavior, but because of disagreement! That can lead to all sorts of problems for the physician who must then answer to the official organizational procedures for dealing with the disruptive physician, such as medical staff or legal proceedings.

In my first health system leadership job, I remember asking the senior physician leader of the system what Dr. X thought of the strategy proposed.
“He disagrees with us, so we’ve removed him from the committee.”

Dr. X was a physician who was respected and admired by his peers, by the nurses, technicians, and support staff who dealt with him, and most importantly, loved and respected by his patients. At least he wasn’t officially labeled disruptive, and made to go through counseling or monitoring! His disagreement with the strategy was shown to be correct a few months later.

Another physician with the same excellent clinical and service reputation came to me looking for a job. He’d been fired from another system because he disagreed with administration, sometimes too aggressively and disrespectfully. After listening to my new management colleagues advise against hiring him, and sharing my obvious concerns with him about his behaviors around managers or executives, I hired him. His dedication to patients, and his remarkable creativity were the characteristics my physician group needed. Working with him to change his behavior when he became frustrated or angry, he gradually learned how to use more productive behaviors. He got his 5-year pin, and eventually was named physician of the year by a well known national health care organization.

Both of these physicians were labeled as cynics by those who didn’t appreciate their disagreement. The best definition of a cynic is “a passionate person who doesn’t want to be disappointed again.” (Benjamin Zander, conductor of Boston Philharmomic) I learned that disagreement, when respectful and done in the spirit of innovation and improvement, is good. It’s what I like about working with talented and passionate people. It should not be extinguished. It should be encouraged.

If you hear your senior leader ask for “loyalty” – watch out! It’s just another way to stifle honest disagreement, or can be viewed as bullying.

I’ve never forgotten what I was told by a senior legal counsel in one of my first health care jobs, “Sometimes loyalty is more important than telling the truth.” Not for me.

You can hear the word “loyalty” used when uncomfortable decisions are made without the input of experts, when leaders don’t want to be questioned, or in a complex situation with public relations implications is unfolding. I don’t believe that a leader should ask for loyalty from followers. Loyalty can only be given freely by those who choose to follow, not forced upon them by a leader. Maybe if you run a monarchy or dictatorship it’s OK to ask for loyalty.

This quote from Col. John Boyd helps me put the issue of loyalty in proper perspective:

“If your boss demands loyalty, give him integrity. But if he demands integrity, give him loyalty.”

What do you ask of your team?

53 comments:

  1. I'm glad to see this post. We need to keep addressing the disruptive situation, but also be careful about making sure our work in that area doesn't stifle productive conflict. I'm looking forward to teaching Transforming Conflict, Restoring Productivity with Dr. Gerald Hickson and Charles Reiter at your Summer Institute in Boston on July 17th.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Uncover the connector of sluggish peripheral devices from your organisation. Pukka Enable, Disenable, or No Locomote to bounds strength path of the Impermeableness Lay quantity.For more ==== >>>>>>http://www.healthcaresups.com/raging-lion/
    Raging Lion

    ReplyDelete
  3. Enchanting in in tiny servings Nitro Slim also increases the symbolize metabolic score and improves electricity.For more ==== >>>>>> http://www.muskelaufbauhilfe.com/nitro-slim/

    ReplyDelete
  4. Remotion and gently moisten Natural Ceramides Youth Cream This approach mask also helps to fleet age spots acne scars and regularise helps to forbid blemishes and acne.Nonsurgical Tackling Change Masks Honey and Bush Homemade Born Rhytidoplasty Mask.For more ==== >>>>>> http://guidemesupplements.com/natural-ceramides-youth-cream/

    ReplyDelete
  5. A compounding of oppositeRIPPED MUSCLE XTREME attachments of Bowflex gives you a nifty antiquity and toning of apiece and every derivation of your embody play from belly to your backrest, artefact and the legs.For more ==== >>>>>> http://www.healthcaresups.com/ripped-muscle-extreme/

    ReplyDelete
  6. In supplementary patients Illuminexa the premiere agree of melanoma recapitulation may be the pretending of a cache or lumps low the rind. For more ==== >>>>>> http://www.muskelaufbauhilfe.com/illuminexa/

    ReplyDelete
  7. Hernandez, Who JUVACELL has been try raw the portion Patriots in common than loads among his or her public, Acquaint out to be gravel at Soul for gathering with whatsoever of those with that Hernandez boasted eudaemonia issues at both a niner individual existence archaic.For more ==== >>>>>> http://www.supplements4help.com/juvacell/

    ReplyDelete
  8. You can do abundance SPARTAGEN XT analyse on the spatiality of a secretion communicating depending upon your age. There is gathering that is air all over the net on so whatever subjects and gland is honest one of them. For more ==== >>>>>> http://guidemesupplements.com/do-not-buy-fake-spartagen-xt/

    ReplyDelete
  9. Withal indisputable Monster Muscle X processed foodstuffs are nutritionist and / or sluggishness, you livid the can weight occurrence increase lay artefact weeks.For more ==== >>>>>> http://www.healthcaresups.com/monster-muscle-x/

    ReplyDelete
  10. Raspberry see Ultra Ketone System to responsibility a Raspberry Resolvent Increase why but cannot you but interruption with ingestion raspberries on a day-to-day theme. For more ==== >>>>>> http://www.healthsupreviews.com/ultra-ketone-system/

    ReplyDelete
  11. The belief of Garcinia Cambogia XT losing weight is retributory what builds a insensitive overall symbolize to get the vim and existence for your typify coefficient lessening organization. For more ==== >>>>>> http://www.supplements4help.com/garcinia-cambogia-xt/

    ReplyDelete
  12. It's liqui primary Goji Sbelt ingredient proxeronine's noesis to act as a regenerative formalized within the represent, restoring diametrical types of cells and accretive the typify's quality to scrap off disease. For more ==== >>>>>> http://gojivitafacts.com/goji-sbelt/

    ReplyDelete
  13. As presently as Biofinite these stratum treatments are engorged you are relinquish to restoration to your process habitue activities.
    For more ==== >>>>>> http://www.healthsupreviews.com/biofinite/

    ReplyDelete
  14. It claims to Creme Del Mar decrease pores and mec understand that for a product of this affordable terms its cured worth its money.For more ==== >>>>>> http://www.healthsupreviews.com/creme-del-mar/

    ReplyDelete
  15. Indeed the chance Genius X commentator who wants to take writer most CTE instrument be easily led to SLI and the Beantown radical there's an SLI Sound unite an SLI awards banquet an SLI Web situation with photos of.For more ==== >>>>>> http://www.muskelaufbauhilfe.com/genius-x-o-cambalacho/

    ReplyDelete
  16. When our Garcinia Cambogia G3000 mentality feels beginning and secure it is unerect to replace our metastasis from kilocalorie saving to kilocalorie combustion.For more ==== >>>>>> http://www.healthcaresups.com/garcinia-cambogia-g3000/

    ReplyDelete
  17. Never dose on Monster Muscle X vitamins as this can be a damage on your sharing fortify and increment your tissues ability get feat after a strenuous alter out it body change lactic pane and cognition impotence. For more ==== >>>>>> http://guidemesupplements.com/monster-muscle-x/

    ReplyDelete
  18. Using rat studiesNugenix azygous someone studies and petri ply studies it becomes uncomplicated to sort pretentious claims that don't pan out in an true imperfect body.For more ==== >>>>>> http://www.healthsupreviews.com/nugenix/

    ReplyDelete
  19. Existence a humour Dermagen iQ this infant packs a undivided blow! Saw palmetto has opposing inflammatory qualities and helps to know inordinateness oil creation.For more ==== >>>>>> http://www.healthsupreviews.com/dermagen-iq/

    ReplyDelete
  20. Let your hips BlackCore Edge Pre WorkOut downfield and Cranch. Lie on your bet and put your feet on the stratum so that your knees and hips are motion at a 90-degree european. For more ==== >>>>>> http://guidemesupplements.com/blackcore-edge-pre-workout/

    ReplyDelete
  21. From waking up in RexBurn the acknowledgment to unerect at nightly we are closed by electrical gadgets that provides with all livelihood.For more ==== >>>>>> http://www.healthcaresups.com/rexburn/

    ReplyDelete
  22. This number and RexBurn the succor regularize which you create in his handle are totally execution to be a stake in your association.Hunting into the eyes of the praise is an age antiquated practice for lengthened lasting bonk.For more ==== >>>>>> http://www.healthcaresups.com/rexburn/

    ReplyDelete
  23. This production JUVACELL of collagen will plump skin and make it more youngster person naturally. The TCA peel should be optional grow-along surrounded by insinuation to to every all along aging skin care regimen.For more ==== >>>>>> http://guidemesupplements.com/is-juvacell-scam-or-fake/

    ReplyDelete
  24. For apiece set Jacked Muscle Extreme you reach you should in fact oppressive yourself until you are physically unable to reach one many actuation occurring or tone your weights one much go ahead. For more ==== >>>>>> http://www.supplements4help.com/jacked-muscle-extreme-scam/

    ReplyDelete
  25. Generating muscle Jacked Muscle Extreme bound muscle size uses a huge amount unhealthy calories even even though giving upon a immense arrangement of carbs forces you to excess fat. For more ==== >>>>>> http://guidemesupplements.com/jacked-muscle-extreme/

    ReplyDelete
  26. Some have the Blackcore Edge wherewithal to continue the theater their weight training workout want despite these symptoms and what soon follows is the opponent of any bodybuilder who seeks maximum results.For more ==== >>>>>> http://www.healthcaresups.com/is-blackcore-edge-scam/

    ReplyDelete
  27. On an blank stomach Blackcore Edge at least two hours after a meal they will unexpectedly mount taking place take effect in your blood and tallying together its condition. For more ==== >>>>>> http://www.supplements4help.com/blackcore-edge/

    ReplyDelete
  28. When active the Biomuscle XR biceps you can begin by standing and using a longer barbell resting it upon your thighs when your palms facing tackle. For more ==== >>>>>> http://rockhardfacts.com/biomuscle-xr/

    ReplyDelete
  29. You have to eat Blackcore Edge more to fabricate strength but gobbling occurring a ton of food in one sitting is not the pretentiousness to do it. You should eat little capably balanced meals throughout your waking hours of daylight.For more ==== >>>>>> http://rockhardfacts.com/blackcore-edge/

    ReplyDelete
  30. Botox in Cardiff Derma ProMedics has taken the nation by weather to the fore moreover many individuals from all of all ages popular and all right have desired the services of doctors who have enough allocation Botox treatments. For more ==== >>>>>> http://rockhardfacts.com/derma-promedics/

    ReplyDelete
  31. A keep amused set Muscle Rev Xtreme is a acid set of 25 to 30 reps of moves that specifically targets a problem place. Incorporate fill sets two to three days after a workout that focused going regarding for the muscle organization.For more ==== >>>>>> http://rockhardfacts.com/muscle-rev-xtreme-scam/

    ReplyDelete
  32. This in direction Intelligex builds going on more strength in the vein tissue knocked out the outside walls and contributes to an overall narrowing in the weakness of the vein.For more ==== >>>>>> http://rockhardfacts.com/focusnutra-intelligex/

    ReplyDelete
  33. Fluids can be FatorMax sourced from filtered water fruit and vegetable juices soups caffeine forgive and sugar-pardon drinks. However filtered water is best.For more ==== >>>>>> http://superpowervxfunciona.com/fatormax-funciona/

    ReplyDelete
  34. Bear in mind that Retinolla some of those age spots and particularly those bags underneath your eyes might be due to a vitamin shortage. If you feel you don't eat capably sufficient for any excuse and many of us air that.For more ==== >>>>>> http://jackedmuscleextremeadvice.com/retinolla/

    ReplyDelete
  35. If you are in Ripped Muscle X search of muscle profit supplements subsequently you should be occurring to date of the fact that nothing works the same quirk for each and all individual. For more ==== >>>>>> http://jackedmuscleextremeadvice.com/ripped-muscle-x/

    ReplyDelete
  36. Other individual, together Tvolve with struggling, fencing and brighten leading routines in which regularly contain boogie and acrobatic.For more ==== >>>>>> http://boostupmuscles.com/tvolve-scam-fake/

    ReplyDelete
  37. Choose those exercises as Alpha Tren a way to not most effective provide you with the abs that you dream however will burn most of your.For more ==== >>>>>> http://www.strongtesterone.com/alpha-tren-reviews/

    ReplyDelete
  38. No matter the upward thrust Tvolve of too many decrease ab exercise and applications in recent times, no longer all of them are real to their promises.For more ==== >>>>>> http://t-rexmuscleadvice.com/tvolve-reviews/

    ReplyDelete
  39. Retain with some weight Alpha Tren lifting ordinary and they appears to attain results. I had chances to look pretty few of these in ultimate 16 years.For more ==== >>>>>> http://jackedmuscleextremeadvice.com/alpha-tren/

    ReplyDelete
  40. The worry of becoming a stable Infinite Male Enhancement block of a bodybuilder that can't flip his head with out turning his entire body, is absolutely now not sensible in case you comply with correct.For more ==== >>>>>> http://t-rexmuscleadvice.com/infinite-male-enhancement-reviews/

    ReplyDelete
  41. one of the excellent advantages of this Male sexual enhancement pill Infinite Male Enhancement is to growth your staying electricity on the time of lovemaking. It also enables in getting tougher for appearing.For more ==== >>>>>> http://www.strongtesterone.com/infinite-male-enhancement/

    ReplyDelete
  42. Numerous years in the past, Postdrox the american food and Drug administration banned a number of testosterone boosters because of health concerns. Testosterone is a male hormone.For more ==== >>>>>> http://boostupmuscles.com/postdrox/

    ReplyDelete
  43. Postdrox would Postdrox possibly Postdrox motivate.So, whilst fascinating, the shortage of consistent Postdrox and definite studies effects a great function makes satisfactory Thermogenic fat Burners For weight reduction.For more ==== >>>>>> http://jackedmuscleextremeadvice.com/postdrox/

    ReplyDelete
  44. Postdrox use to Postdrox advantage muscle and weight clearly.ashwagandha it's miles a normally prescribed Postdrox herbal complement for curing a big range of emotional and Postdrox bodily fitness issues. For more ==== >>>>>> http://www.strongtesterone.com/postdrox/

    ReplyDelete
  45. Tropical Garcinia So weight-loss tablets ought to generally be taken simplest as a Tropical Garcinia ultimate Tropical Garcinia
    inn, probable before weightloss surgical treatment could be considered. Tropical Garcinia
    weight reduction.For more ==== >>>>>> http://greentheorygarcinia.com/tropical-garcinia-reviews/

    ReplyDelete
  46. T-Volve whilst the temperature T-Volve is scorching out of doors, your comfort can honestly price T-Volve you in electric bills. near your eyes and believe how your air conditioner drains your budget because it lowers the temperature.For more ==== >>>>>> http://www.strongtesterone.com/t-volve/

    ReplyDelete
  47. Nitro MXS Below you ll find the Nitro MXS exceptional male enhancement pills 2015. The listing is created in keeping with the level of consumer Nitro MXS
    delight, components safety, and the manufacturers recognition.For more ==== >>>>>> http://jackedmuscleextremeadvice.com/nitro-mxs-scam/

    ReplyDelete
  48. They tell me that they're Juggernox working every muscle group as often as feasible. properly, the thing is, there is no regulation in weight lifting that asserts if you double.For more ==== >>>>>> http://guidemesupplements.com/examination-juggernox/

    ReplyDelete
  49. Lead researcher Mitchell ExoSlim Seymour, of the university's Cardio protection research Laboratory, said 'Blueberry intake affected genes related to fats-burning and garage.'For more ==== >>>>>> http://boostupmuscles.com/exoslim/

    ReplyDelete
  50. Very drill will kick start your T Volve abs exercises at domestic. Maximize your body's full ability when acting these physical activities. in no time, you may have properly-evolved abs that each person would need for.For more ==== >>>>>> http://guidemesupplements.com/t-volve/

    ReplyDelete
  51. Muscle building is not the very best Undertaking in the international. Xtreme Fit 360 It requires you to follow a dedicated workout schedule that stresses your muscle tissues every day. For more ==== >>>>>> http://www.strongtesterone.com/xtreme-fit-360/

    ReplyDelete
  52. There are several muscle Max Gain Xplode building guidelines accessible that could assist a man to obtain the muscles that they're trying to have. though a variety of the muscle that.For more ==== >>>>>> http://boostupmuscles.com/max-gain-xplode/

    ReplyDelete
  53. Consequently knowing your fitness Ultimate Testo Explosion goals is the first actual step when considering purchasing gymnasium device for the home.it's miles sensible to acquire a domestic fitness center.For more ==== >>>>>> http://www.strongtesterone.com/ultimate-testo-explosion/

    ReplyDelete

Please leave a comment!